Only two Arsenal players scored above five out of ten in a brutal set of ratings from L'Equipe on Tuesday evening.
The Gunners stumbled to a 2-2 draw with Bayern Munich in the first leg of their Champions League quarter-final at the Emirates, with a Leandro Trossard equaliser 14 minutes from time salvaging a draw for Mikel Arteta's men.
Though they were denied a late penalty when Bukayo Saka hit the deck under challenge from Manuel Neuer in stoppage time, Arsenal were far from their best and failed to show the form that has taken them to the top of the Premier League this season.
They will now head to the German capital next week perhaps up against the odds, needing to win the game outright with the score all square heading into the English side's away leg.
Their poor performance, meanwhile, was reflected in the ratings from the French publication, with just two players reaching a score of six out of the 11 starters and manager Arteta.
Arsenal players were brutalised in their player ratings from L'Equipe from their draw with Bayern Munich
Bukayo Saka (L) and Martin Odegaard (R) were the only two players to score over 5/10
Defender William Saliba, meanwhile, scored just 3/10 in one of his more disappointing performances of the season
L-Equipe, who are notoriously critical when giving out their ratings, handed both Saka and Gunners captain Martin Odegaard a six out of ten.
Elsewhere, there were five four of of tens handed out, as the defence, which has been by far the best in the Premier League this season, was criticised by the publication.
William Saliba in particular, who has starred for Arsenal this term but struggled to nail down a position in the French national team, received a three out of ten on the back of what was on of his most disappointing showings of the campaign.
'The Frenchman missed the opportunity to extend his remarkable season in the Premier League on the European stage,' the publication wrote of his performance. 'First at fault on Bayern's first goal, by being too short on the decisive passer, Leon Goretzka.
'Saliba then caused the penalty which will be transformed by Kane. The former Marseillais was also not very well placed in the action leading to Kingsley Coman's shot being pushed back by the post.'
Jakub Kiwior, again playing at left back and being rated a four out of ten, was also listed in the 'flops' section of the ratings, alongside Salbia in what was a night to forget for a usually-solid Gunners defence.
'The Polish full-back suffered a lot against the speed and excellent ball handling of Leroy Sane,' was written of his showing. Involved in the first goal conceded by his team, since he missed a pass sent to him by Gabriel, Kiwior also had very little influence in the construction of his team's play, touching only 27 balls, before being logically replaced at the break by [Oleksandr] Zinchenko.'
The attacking Arsenal players didn't fare much better, with Declan Rice, Kai Havertz and Gabriel Martinelli all receiving a five out of ten for their performances.
Arsenal's team received an average rating of 4.6/10, with five players scoring 4/10 and three 5/10
Full-back Jakub Kiwior scored 4/10 was was listed in L'Equipe's list of flop from the match
The criticism wasn't just aimed at Arsenal, however. Much of the spotlight was on Harry Kane - who received a six out of ten - upon his return to the Emirates after leaving arch rivals Tottenham for Bayern in the summer, but former Spurs man was also returning having completed the same transfer in January.
Dier has received widespread criticism for his performances since his move to Germany, but has continued to receive the trust of outgoing manager Thomas Tuchel, making 12 appearances for the club so far.
He didn't have quite the performance of Kane, however, also being handed a three out of ten by L'Equipe.
Harry Kane (L) and Eric Dier (R) returned to the Emirates for the first time since leaving Tottenham, with Dier rated 3/10
'Alongside Matthijs de Ligt in central defense, he did not convince,' they wrote. 'Lacking aggressiveness in duels, his raises were too often risky.
'His slowness constitutes a real obstacle at the highest European level. He didn't know how to seize his chance.'