Climate investment gap looms over next EU mandate

9 months ago 56

Hello and a big welcome to our new subscribers from Iberdrola, Vattenfall, Qenergy, and more. Euractiv’s Green Brief brings you a roundup of energy and environment news from across Europe. You can subscribe here.

Green finance hole. If the EU’s 2030 climate goals are to be met, an annual investment gap of €406 billion must be filled, according to new research published on Wednesday (21 February).

This is the main finding of the first-ever “European Climate Investment Deficit report” by the Institute for Climate Economics (I4CE), a think-tank chaired by Jean Pisani-Ferry, a former chief advisor to the French government.

According to the research, at least €813 billion is needed annually across 22 sectors of the economy in order to meet the EU’s 2030 decarbonisation target.

“As real-economy investments reached €407 billion in 2022, this leaves a European climate investment deficit of €406 billion per year, or 2.6% GDP,” the report states, adding that investments “must still double for the EU to hit 2030 climate targets”. Frédéric Simon has the details.

The trillion-euro question. The European Commission itself acknowledges that huge investments will be necessary to meet the EU’s climate goals.

In its 2040 climate policy recommendations, presented on 6 February, the EU executive said a combined €1.5 trillion will be needed annually in 2030-2050 just to meet the EU’s decarbonisation targets in energy and transport alone.

However, it left the question of funding open, saying only that “a comprehensive investment agenda” combining public and private finance will be needed to achieve the EU’s decarbonisation objectives.

According to I4CE, closing the green investment gap will require “a comprehensive approach” involving regulations, carbon pricing policies, and “some additional EU public funding”.

Von der Leyen to the rescue? The I4CE report is being presented in Brussels today as EU institutions prepare for the next five-year mandate (2024-2029) following the June European elections.

Commission President Ursula von der Leyen threw her hat into the ring on Monday by announcing her candidacy to run for a second term at the helm of the EU executive as the lead candidate for the centre-right European People’s Party (EPP).

Von der Leyen already outlined what her green policy programme could look like in her annual State of the Union speech, delivered in September. “As we enter the next phase of the European Green Deal, one thing will never change. We will keep supporting European industry throughout this transition,” she said back then.

A key plank of von der Leyen’s programme is the “industry decarbonisation deal” outlined in the Commission’s recommendation for a 2040 climate target.

“The Green Deal now needs to become an industrial decarbonisation deal” with a focus on ramping up the EU’s “domestic manufacturing” capabilities in green technologies, the Commission said when it presented its 2040 climate plan.

Industrial deal. On Tuesday, von der Leyen confirmed those intentions when she appeared in the Belgian Port of Antwerp to meet a coalition of 73 industry leaders – in sectors ranging from steelmaking to chemicals – who presented their pleas for the next EU mandate.

The ‘Antwerp Declaration for a European Industrial Deal’, presented to von der Leyen, highlighted the “urgent need for clarity, predictability, and confidence in Europe and its industrial policy”.

The declaration urges von der Leyen to adopt an “omnibus proposal to take corrective measures on all relevant existing EU regulation” as her first initiative if she is re-appointed for a second term by EU leaders.

Other demands include cheaper energy – by eliminating regulatory charges, improving grid integration and forging “partnerships with resource-rich countries” for the supply of raw materials needed for the green transition. All in all, Europe’s industry is calling for a “new spirit of law-making”. Niko Kurmayer has the details.

First things first. But before seeking the endorsement of EU leaders, von der Leyen first needs to be nominated by the government in her own country – Germany –, which is currently ruled by an alliance of Socialists, Greens and Liberals. Nick Alipour has the story.

Backing from the same parties will also be crucial for von der Leyen to secure a majority in the European Parliament after the June EU elections. Back in 2019, von der Leyen was only confirmed by a paper-thin majority in the EU assembly, thanks to the support of the socialists and liberals.

With the EPP’s majority set to be eroded further after the EU election, this means von der Leyen will need to forge a centrist coalition to win a Parliamentary majority – and defend the European Green Deal in the face of opposition from hardline conservatives and the far-right. A tough balancing act.

“For us Greens, a very central issue will be whether Ursula von der Leyen intends to continue to stand behind the Green Deal to work on it despite the potentially increased pressure coming from a rising far right,” said Henrike Hahn, a Green MEP. Alexandra Brzozowski has more.

Super Mario to the rescue? From Thursday to Saturday, EU finance ministers will be meeting in Ghent to discuss the EU’s competitiveness and investment agenda for the next five-year mandate.

Items on the agenda include future policies of the European Investment Bank (EIB) and a working session with former European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi, who was tasked in September with preparing a report on the future of Europe’s competitiveness.

However, their room for manoeuvre is constrained by the EU’s Stability and Growth Pact, which limits public debt and deficits to 60% and 3% of GDP respectively.

EU countries agreed on a reform of spending rules earlier this month, but made only limited extra room available for green investments, under pressure from “frugal” countries like Germany who want to reinstate strict EU spending rules that were suspended during the COVID-19 pandemic and the energy crisis.

“It is important that sufficient fiscal space is preserved in Member States for investment, within the frame of medium- to long-term debt sustainability,” the Commission remarked in its 2040 climate target communication.

Big oil profits top €260bn since start of Ukraine war: report – By Nathan Canas
State subsidies for industry: Brussels greenlights €4bn German initiative – By Nikolaus J. Kurmayer
European Commission backtracks on Water Resilience Initiative – By Nathan Canas
Solar PV industry caught up in China forced-labour controversy – By Nikolaus J. Kurmayer
Lawmakers back EU law to cut food and textile waste – By Nathan Canas
EU lawmakers back hefty fines for companies making false green claims – By Frédéric Simon
Europe ‘getting more dependent on China’ for clean tech, EU climate chief warns – By Frédéric Simon

PRAGUE. Special EU fund for coal regions looks good but is costly, warns Czech study. Creating a new European fund to support coal regions – the Just Transition Fund – may look like a positive step for disadvantaged areas, but its administration is complex, costly and threatens its effective use, warns a new Czech study based on interviews with officials. Read more.

COPENHAGEN. State aid should be ‘stopped’, Danish industry minister warns. The current loosening of EU state aid rules should not be prolonged further, Danish Industry Minister Morten Bødskov warned on Tuesday while in Berlin to meet his German counterpart, Robert Habeck, a fierce proponent of relaxation of the EU framework. Read more.

PRAGUE. Czech steel industry unprepared for EU decarbonisation. The Czech steel industry is unprepared for decarbonisation, not only technologically but also financially, making it challenging to implement the EU’s decarbonisation plans, experts say. Read more.

BUCHAREST. Romania to maintain the same energy price cap for another year. Romania’s cap on energy prices will remain unchanged until March 2025, announced Romanian Energy Minister Sebastian Burduja on Thursday, meaning Romanian consumers will continue enjoying the EU’s fourth cheapest gas prices. Read more.

NICOSIA. Cyprus could produce first natural gas as soon as 2026, minister says. Cyprus could start producing its first natural gas as soon as 2026, and plans to participate in a high-powered electricity cable project linking the eastern Mediterranean to continental Europe. Read more.

SOFIA. Bulgaria is looking for a strategic buyer for Lukoil Neftochim in the US. The “need to find a strategic buyer” for the Lukoil Neftochim refinery in Burgas and possibilities of reducing dependence on Russian gas and oil in the Balkan region were discussed by a Bulgarian government delegation during its visit to the US, the Finance Ministry said on Wednesday. Read more.

EU carbon emissions down 7.1% in Q3 2023: Eurostat. The EU’s statistical office Eurostat published on Wednesday (14 February) updated figures on greenhouse gas emissions for 2023.

In the third quarter (Q3), greenhouse gas emissions in the EU27 fell by 7.1% compared with the same quarter of the previous year (847 million tonnes of CO2e in Q3 2022 compared with 787 million tonnes of CO2e in Q3 2023).

The economic sectors that delivered the biggest reductions were electricity and gas (-23.7%), households (-6.5%) and manufacturing industry (-4.9%).

Among EU Member States, only Malta (+7.7%), Cyprus (+3.7%), Latvia (+3.4%) and Slovakia (+0.9%) saw their emissions increase. On the contrary, the biggest reductions in greenhouse gas emissions were recorded for Estonia (-30.7%), Bulgaria (-18.6%) and Germany (-12.2%). (Nathan Canas | Euractiv.com)

Romania raises €2 bln from debut green bond. Romania will raise €2 billion from its first ever green bond launched on Thursday (15 February), Refinitiv and IFR data showed, as the country seeks to diversify its investor base and tap into growing demand for environmentally focused debt.

Bucharest has spent more than a year preparing the framework needed to issue green bonds and treasury chief Stefan Nanu told Reuters in December the country planned its first benchmark-sized issue in the first half of 2024.

Green bonds fund expenditures beneficial to the environment and governments across Europe have launched sizable issues.

Romania, which already has a slate of renewable energy projects lined up for EU funding, will use its green debt framework to fund green transport links, buildings’ energy efficiency and reforestation plans among others. (Euractiv.com with Reuters)

Beggars can’t be choosers – Europe needs to smarten up its energy security – By Giulia Cretti and Louise van Schaik
Sanctions against Russian LNG already have impact and can work even better – By Mykola Kolisnyk

2024 – Q1. Commission proposals:
- - Communication on water resilience
  - Communication on advanced materials for industrial leadership

22 FEBRUARY. Clean transition dialogue on clean tech chaired by Šefčovič and von der Leyen
26-29 FEBRUARY. Parliament plenary
- - Final vote on Nature Restoration Law

4 MARCH:

- - Trilogue on Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation
  - Energy Council
11-14 MARCH. Parliament plenary
- - Vote on Waste Framework Directive
  - Vote on ‘Green claims’ directive
12 MARCH. Climate resilience and adaptation package
20-21 MARCH. European Council
25 MARCH. Environment Council

10 April. Stocktaking on the clean transition dialogues.

10-11 APRIL. Parliament Mini-Plenary (Brussels)

15-16 APRIL. Informal Energy Council

22-25 APRIL. Last Parliament plenary session before the European elections
- Circularity requirements for vehicle design and on management of end-of-life vehicles

30 MAY. Energy Council
SPRING 2024. First European Climate Risk Assessment
6-9 JUNE: European elections
17 JUNE. Environment Council (Luxembourg)
27-28 JUNE. European Council

Edited by Nathalie Weatherald and Frédéric Simon. Interested in more energy and environment news delivered to your inbox? You can subscribe to our daily newsletter and to our comprehensive weekly update here.