'There's no way she didn't recognize her': Shock twist in case of high school imposter Shelby Hewitt and the therapist who took her in

Questions have been asked about the therapist who, with her boyfriend, took in the 32-year-old social worker who masqueraded as a traumatized high schooler for almost a year. 

Shelby Hewitt, also known as 'Ellie Blake', 13, and 'Daniella Blake Herrerra', 16, conned her way into three high schools and a treatment center, even tricking a therapist and her partner into becoming her foster parents. 

Students who bullied her for looking like she was in her 30s - including taunts that 'white cracks early' - were disciplined, even though an investigation found they were right all along. 

New information has come out about someone who had access to Hewitt's innermost thoughts and feelings: her therapist, Rebecca Bernat. 

At some stage, she began living with Bernat, a social therapist at Walden Behavioral Care (who later fired her), and her partner John Smith, seemingly without documentation as the couple claimed they were duped along with everyone else. 

Hewitt reportedly told Bernat that she came up with aliases to hide from those who had abused and trafficked her as a child, including 'Daniella.' 

At some point, Daniella became the real name she went by, while she also claimed she had been homeless, which led to the couple taking Hewitt in.

Bernat not only did that but helped her get into three different schools in Boston - first as Daniella and later as Ellie - as well as advocating for special services, according to the Boston Globe. 

A former Walden employee is speaking out, claiming they refuse to believe Bernat could have been so naïve. 

The employee, who remained anonymous, said that Hewitt and Bernat would have met previously when she was admitted twice between 2018 and 2020.

The anonymous colleague believes Bernat would have known her under her real name.

'In no way do I think she was hosed. She would definitely refer to her as Shelby' in meetings, they claimed, but then switched to Daniella and saying that she agreed to be her therapist because of how challenging the case was. 

Another anonymous colleague echoes these allegations. 

'I don't think of her as being taken. Becky was very savvy at seeing through that behavior,' they argue.

Someone who did go on the record was Liza Campiglio, a roommate of Hewitt's when they were both patients at Walden in 2019. 

'There's no way she didn't recognize her,' Campiglio says. 

A number of anonymous officials with the Boston school system also cast doubt on her version of events and say she's taken advantage of the system.

Connie Tran, Bernat's lawyer, explained to the Globe via email how the couple were bamboozled. 

'Hewitt utilized various fabricated personas to deceive Walden, BPS and Rebecca into believing she was in fact a child who was legally in DCF's custody.' 

'Rebecca did not facilitate Shelby Hewitt's enrollment into BPS; rather, Hewitt undertook this action independently,' she added.

There have also been wonders by the anonymous sources whether the possibility that Hewitt had money led them to act the way she did. Tran adamantly denies it.

'Rebecca received no compensation for taking on a role that she perceived was legitimate,' she wrote. 

While Bernat and Smith have faced an investigation, no criminal charges have been filed. 

'The story of Shelby Hewitt's various fabricated identities is no doubt complex,' Tran wrote. 

'Rebecca Bernat, relying on all of the information presented to Walden Behavioral, earnestly believed the individual before her was an adolescent in need of help and a home.' 

Bernat and Smith have said they were unaware of her double life, and Smith was reportedly known to routinely show up to support his foster daughter at high school basketball games.

The therapist was later fired from her role as a social worker for failing to go through the proper channels in taking who she thought was a troubled teen into her home, but maintains that she and her partner were also victims. 

'The criminal defendant deceived and victimized John Smith and Rebecca Bernat,' their attorneys told the Globe. 'John and Rebecca are among numerous people who genuinely believed a desperate young person was in need.'

The reasons for the alleged fraud are still unclear, as an investigation into her ongoing court case by the Boston Globe saw former classmates and furious parents question how she pulled it off. 

'Why did you do this?' tricked friend Janell Lamons questioned to the outlet. 'I feel betrayed and confused.'

Hewitt is charged with criminal forgery and identity fraud, and after she pleaded not guilty in December, she is set to stand trial at the end of the year. 

According to prosecutors, she began her elaborate plot by pretending to be troubled 16-year-old Daniella Blake Herrera in mid-2022, shortly after she returned to work at the Department of Children and Families (DCF). 

Graduating with her master's degree in school counseling from the University of Massachusetts, Boston in 2016, she was initially hired by the DCF right out of graduate school on a $50,000 salary. 

She left in 2018, around the same time her mother and maternal grandfather passed away, leaving her with a large inheritance speculated to be as much as $1 million. 

It is unclear what exactly Hewitt was doing for around three years, until prosecutors say she began the fraud in December 2021 by registering an email domain - @masstate.us - intended to look like a legitimate Massachusetts DCF email. 

She then allegedly created emails for two fake social workers who would claim to be working for her - Michael Kornetsky and Michelle Delfi. 

Prosecutor Ashley Polin alleged in court that while 'posing behind the keyboard as one of these DCF workers', Hewitt 'had herself admitted as a child patient at the Walden Behavioral treatment center and enrolled herself in the Boston Public Schools.'  The treatment center helped youngsters with eating disorders, with Hewitt having long-suffered anorexia. 

From there, she quickly began attending classes at Jeremiah E. Burke High School in Dorchester, where she stayed for around seven months before transferring to Brighton High for two months. 

Switching to the name Ellie Blake and claiming to be 13, her alleged con unraveled a week after she transferred to English High School in Boston. The scheme was busted after she complained about being bullied by actual-teenagers taunting her for looking like an adult. 

At some point, Hewitt had also purchased a $350,000 apartment, paying for the property in cash rather than needing a mortgage.  

Despite committing to the facade by even having braces put on her teeth, as well as regularly wearing baggy clothes and ponytails to give her a younger look, classmates ridiculed Hewitt for appearing to look more like their parents. 

The school was predominantly black and Hispanic students, who reportedly told Hewitt, 'White cracks early.'  

Posing as fake social worker Michelle Delfi using the bogus Massachusetts state email Hewitt created, she emailed the school's guidance counselor to notify them about the bullying she claimed Ellie was suffering. 

'Elle has a really bad day at school yesterday, cried all evening and doesn't want to go back,' the message said - with Hewitt allegedly writing about herself in the third person. 

'(Ellie) is really sensitive about people commenting on her face and how she looks older,' Ms. 'Delphi' wrote. 'It's a huge trigger point for her.' 

Delphi said that Ellie suffered from a genetic medical condition that prematurely aged her, and claimed she was a vulnerable victim of child trafficking that now lived with a foster family. 

After school staff worked out a plan for her return, principal Caitlin Murphy realized certain aspects of the troubled student's story didn't add up - most notably, Delphi's email domain didn't match the correct DCF address. 

In an email seen by the Boston Globe, Murphy urgently requested staff members 'look at the documents that Ellie was registered with to be sure that we are confident that there is not something amiss here.'

'Something feels like it's not adding up,' she wrote. They were later disturbed at being unable to find her birth certificate. 

Claiming that her parents were dead, Hewitt was also able to enroll under a false identity at Walden Behavioral Care, which specializes in eating disorders. 

Other classmates also claimed she exhibited strange behavior, including randomly bursting into tears in class and hallways, and driving herself to school while saying her family were so poor they were struggling for food. 

Despite the inconsistencies, classmates said her tragic backstory meant they merely felt sorry for her, as friend Janell Lamons, 15, said: 'Me and my friends felt really bad for her.' 

Lamons met Hewitt while at Burke High, and introduced her to her friends as the new kid in school that she had empathy for. 

'She said her foster mother didn't have money and sometimes ran out of food,' she said, adding that Hewitt also occasionally slipped up and altered her story. 

Following Hewitt's arrest in June 2023, Lamons' mother Robin Williams said she was stunned at how the alleged con had worked, as the case still leaves more questions than answers. 

'To find out this 32-year-old is sitting in class with my daughter and other kids, and she jumped to three different schools, it was scary,' she told the Boston Globe. 

Before she was foiled, Hewitt maintained the facade by playing on the girls' basketball team, gossiping with friends half her age, and handing in homework - all while still working as a DCF social worker full-time. 

Insiders claimed to the outlet that while surprising, flaws in the system mean some social workers can skate by doing the bare minimum, helped by the fact that families under DCF supervision 'don't want to see you, so they are not going to complain.' 

Friends from college also recall seeing Hewitt shortly before her arrest, where they said nothing appeared out of the ordinary, except for the braces she had fitted to her teeth. 

However, Hewitt's house of cards came down on June 14, 2023, when Principal Murphy noticed that not only did the email domain not match DCF, but a letter supposedly from the body had a typo in its logo, noting it was from the 'Department of Children rind Families.' 

The school called DCF to speak with Delphi about the mysterious case, only to be told that nobody with that name worked there. 

Due to flaws in the enrollment system and staff wanting to help a seemingly helpless teenager, Murphy found they didn't possess basic paperwork, including a birth certificate. 

'I assumed we had some sort of information from DCF regarding the arrangement with the foster parents — we've had no reason to doubt anyone calling before,' she wrote in an email to staff at the time. 

'But in retrospect we should have asked for some formal paperwork.' 

Hewitt was promptly questioned by police, and she initially claimed Delphi was forging documents to encourage Bernat to take her into foster care. 

Hewitt reportedly later confessed to the con, as the outlet says she responded to a request for comment in a phone call by telling a reporter that 'there is a reason' she pretended to be a teen, but her attorneys told her to stay quiet during her ongoing case. 

She said the truth 'will come out in time' - but until then, the 32-year-old's motivation for the alleged year-long con remains a mystery.